Louie's Pizza Elmhurst, Queens · 81-34 Baxter Ave ★ 4.9 · 95 Google reviews · (718) 440-9346 $150 tier Amore Pizzeria Flushing, Queens · 30-27 Stratton St ★ 4.6 · 194 Google reviews · (718) 445-0579 $150 tier Pizza Palace Inwood, Manhattan · 121 Dyckman St ★ 4.7 · 184 Google reviews · (212) 567-9588 $150 tier Tommy's Pizza Throggs Neck, Bronx · 4033 E Tremont Ave ★ 4.8 · 51 Google reviews · (718) 829-2828 $150 tier Margherita Pizza Jamaica, Queens · 163-04 Jamaica Ave ★ 4.9 · 284 Google reviews · (718) 657-5780 $150 tier Three Boys From Italy Bronx (Burke Ave) · 704 Burke Ave ★ 4.8 · 86 Google reviews · (718) 882-2009 $150 tier Pizza Wagon Bay Ridge, Brooklyn · 8610 5th Ave ★ 4.8 · 143 Google reviews · (718) 836-5725 $150 tier Rosa's Pizza Ridgewood, Queens · 62-65 Fresh Pond Rd ★ 4.7 · 139 Google reviews · (718) 497-7672 $150 tier New Yankee Pizza Bronx (Westchester Ave) · 1616 Westchester Ave ★ 4.3 · 182 Google reviews · (718) 378-4488 $150 tier Smiling Pizzeria Park Slope, Brooklyn · 323 7th Ave ★ 4.5 · 166 Google reviews · (718) 788-2137 $150 tier